Uneven playing field: the state of Australia’s schools




Education is at once the great social mobiliser and the great leveller in our society. Educated citizens are safeguards in our democracy, and an educated workforce is vital to a productive, innovative and entrepreneurial economy. Education breaks the shackles of disadvantage and empowers those who live without privilege.

But how fair and accessible are Australia’s schools? Almost five years on since the Gonski Review, are we making progress?

CPD latest report, Uneven playing field: the state of Australia’s schools, takes a look at these questions. It is co-authored by CPD Fellow Chris Bonnor and Bernie Shepherd, who between them have 80 years of experience as NSW principals and education policy experts.

Download Uneven playing field

Specifically, we find that the equity of Australia’s schools has deteriorated in recent years.

Our school system is straying into a hierarchy of advantage and disadvantage.

The students who are able to move to schools perceived to be better are doing so in increasing numbers, which is compounding the struggle of those students left behind at
other schools.

Examining key data from the My School website, the report shows:

  • Equity in our schools is declining – Family and personal background are having a greater impact on student achievement than is desirable in an open, accessible system like ours.
  • Students who have the means are shifting to different schools – Enrolment growth in more advantaged schools is growing strongly while enrolment growth in more disadvantaged schools is well below the national average.
  • A schools hierarchy is hardening along advantage/disadvantage lines – Disadvantaged students are increasingly concentrated in disadvantaged schools, and the educational challenges for these students are compounding as a result.
  • The local school is becoming detached from its surrounding neighbourhoods – The local public school is increasingly less representative of the local area because many students are attending school elsewhere. The connections the local school has with the community are breaking down.
  • Government funding is converging across government and non-government schools – Based on current trends, by 2016-17 the recurrent government funding that non-government schools receive converge with, then outstrip, that received by the public schools in a similar socio-economic range.

The report argues that the current government policies and funding arrangements are wholly unsustainable, and recommends four key things overall:

  • Revitalise Gonski – Policymakers should revising the findings and establish the mechanisms recommended by the Review – including a National Schools Resourcing Body to drive implementation of a Schools Resourcing Standard.
  • Level the playing field for schools and students – Federal and state governments to commit to full funding of all the Gonski recommendations as a high priority. If additional funding is not forthcoming, governments should rebalance the funding mix towards additional investment in schools with greatest need, regardless of sector. This should include a review of those schools where current finding levels are much greater than for other schools with similar enrolment profiles, differ markedly from other schools with similar enrolments, and a hold in growth in public funding for non-government schools pending a review of how funding is distributed and what obligations should accompany public funding.
  • Restore the local school – Policy should focus on maximising opportunities for all children to enrol and succeed in their most accessible local school.
  • Reduce the impact of disadvantage on student outcomes – The clear relationship between social disadvantage and poor educational outcomes – driven in part by separation of students with socio-educational advantage – must be addressed as an urgent priority. Incentives available to certain schools to aggregate advantage should be progressively reduced, and the capacity of less advantaged schools to offer excellent education to all students and families in a community must be increased.
Uneven playing field

In the Media

The gap between high and low socioeconomic high schools is widening as struggling schools are left to support the most disadvantaged students, a new report has found. Research from the Centre for Policy and Development, released on Wednesday, reveals that
The education gulf is widening with the numbers of high achieving HSC students increasingly concentrated in advantaged schools at the expense of disadvantaged schools, new research shows. Aspirational parents are driving the shift as they "trade up" schools for educational institutions
For some the news that arrived in the post earlier this month would have been good, perhaps even life changing. Many more would have disappointed. Each July across NSW the state’s selective high schools notify students who were successful in their
Whenever the selective school debate flares, students at those schools feel picked on. Their only crime is to have worked hard, so to them the discussion feels like an accusation – that they are undeserving, or swindled their way in
Though long regarded as the great equalisers of education, a new study has revealed selective schools are now eclipsing elite, high-fee private schools when it comes to advantage. Over half of the state’s twenty most socio-educationally advantaged schools are now selective,
In the debate about selective schools personal stories and beliefs can drown out evidence, especially when that evidence challenges the status quo. So we hear plenty of anecdotes about the successes of selective school students, but relatively few about the
Selective schools have overtaken private schools as the state's most advantaged, with schools such as Normanhurst Boys and Hornsby Girls now eclipsing elite colleges such as St Ignatius, Barker and Ascham.
The first thing I did when I became a secondary school principal many years ago was to put the school’s prefects in blazers and ties. The school was losing enrolments and needed to improve its profile; prefects were put in
We are now into the tenth anniversary of the strategy to close the gap between Indigenous and non-Indigenous Australia. Last week saw a report on progress, a subdued celebration on scattered achievements and copious hand-wringing over endemic failures.