The 2021 Hutley opinion on directors duties and climate risk is a new supplementary legal opinion by Noel Hutley SC and Sebastian Hartford Davis on climate change and directors’ duties. It was released by the Centre for Policy Development in April 2021.
It was provided on instruction from Sarah Barker of MinterEllison, and builds on earlier Hutley-Hartford Davis opinions released by the Centre for Policy Development 2016 and 2019.
The 2021 Hutley opinion emphasises that the bar for directors continues to rise amidst surging global action on climate, and highlights legal risks associated with “greenwashing” – including around corporate net zero emissions commitments – as scrutiny of climate-related targets grows.
Accelerating impacts of climate change, and responses to climate change overseas and domestically, are profoundly influencing, positively and negatively, the interests of many Australian businesses. It is now perfectly clear that reasonable directors and firms should foresee these risks. We would caution against any misrepresentation about the steps such directors and firms may be taking in response.– 2021 Hutley Opinion
– 2021 Hutley Opinion
The 2021 Hutley opinion on directors duties and climate change expands on the issues explored in earlier opinion in 2019 and 2016.
It highlights legal risks associated with greenwashing as scrutiny of climate-related targets grows.
The 2021 Hutley Opinion emphasises the increasing standard of care expected of directors in managing climate-related risks and opportunities, and highlights legal risks surrounding “greenwashing”, especially as scrutiny of climate-related disclosures and commitments grows.
Its key findings are:
The landmark 2016 Hutley opinion found that directors who do not properly manage climate risks could be held liable for breaching their legal duty of due care and diligence.
The 2019 Hutley opinion emphasised that the standard of care expected of directors in addressing climate risks had been raised by a series developments, and that directors’ exposure to climate change litigation was “increasing, probably exponentially, with time”.
The 2021 Hutley opinion follows a 2020 roundtable with Noel Hutley SC and colleagues on directors’ duties and climate change.
The roundtable examined critical challenges and flashpoints for directors and trustees seeking to meet their climate-related obligations.